New here? Register in under one minute   Already a member? Login245057 questions, 1084625 answers  

  DearCupid.ORG relationship advice
  Got a relationship, dating, love or sex question? Ask for help!Search
 New Questions Answers . Most Discussed Viewed . Unanswered . Followups . Forums . Top agony aunts . About Us .  Articles  . Sitemap

Husband after marriage asked about my past and then served me with divorce papers!

Tagged as: Marriage problems, Trust issues<< Previous question   Next question >>
Question - (5 October 2010) 16 Answers - (Newest, 10 October 2010)
A female United States age 41-50, *ahra writes:

My husband and I are married for 10 months. Right after we got married he strictly asked me if there was anything about my past I wanted to share. So I believe in you marry your best friend and I told him somethings that I had done that I'm not so proud about. He freaked out and left. Went to stay with Family but then called and said he needed some time to think about it and get over the images. He came back and I said it was my past I can't change it. He said how could I even think of doing such things no respectable person does that. He said he made a mistake getting married. I was heartbroken and cried and said sorry I didnt tell him before. I said I want a different life and make things better. Every now and then he kept bringing it up saying other things like he can't picture me being the mother of his kids. He wanted me to stop drinking, stop seeing some friends, I did it all to make it work. Finally I found out he was checking my email constantly. I asked him why doesn't he trust me he said how can I when this marriage is based on a lie. I said OK either we push through and work this out or you can leave. I said I have tried everythign to make you happy. He said yes he loves me and wants to work it out. 2 weeks later I asked him hey things dont feel right are you OK are you bored. He replied that there is a lot of thinking to do. He's not sure if he wants to be with me he doesn't like my relaxed attitude about drinking and the type of friends I keep. I finally got pissed I said you know I thought we were working on US I don't like to be in limbo where I'm not sure when you will break up with me. I said please go think somewhere else. When I came home that night there were divorce papers ready for me.

I was so heartbroken but I signed them. I was just exahausted. The next day he was acting like nothing happened and said Hi baby would you like to go for dinner. I was in shock. I said I'm sorry this is the hardest thing for me to do. But you have to leave. We are broken after last night.

I drove him to the taxi stand, and he left with a head shake. I got a skype message from him saying he loves me but is sorry this couldn't work out. Our paths are not the same respectively. He said he chose his path and he hopes I find mine. Last good bye.

It's been 3 weeks. I am a roller caoster of emotion. I think about all the good things and cry and just can't believe he can cut ties. When will I get over this. I didnt respnd to him and dont plan to.

View related questions: best friend, divorce, heartbroken

<-- Rate this Question

Reply to this Question


Share

Fancy yourself as an agony aunt? Add your answer to this question!

A female reader, YouWish United States +, writes (10 October 2010):

YouWish agony auntYes, this is absolutely retroactive jealousy. The guy is a bonehead for waiting until he's married to ask you a question like that. Also, he's forgetting that he too has a past.

If he wants to break up with you because of something you did before you married him, he certainly can. You're better off without him checking your emails and dictating to you how you're allowed to live.

Our past is a tapestry that shapes who we are today. We can't get rid of the bad parts, and truthfully, we don't want to, because we have learned valuable lessons from our failures, emotional exploration, and success. If you hadn't had the past you had, you wouldn't have been the woman he fell in love with.

Please don't fall into the "I'm not good enough for someone to be with" rut because this guy is too immature to deal with the fact that everyone, including him, has a past.

I think that he'll realize the mistake he's made. I hope you don't allow him to waltz back into your life if he has the change of heart. YOU did nothing wrong.

Listen, I know it hurts, but I'm telling you that you need to be with a guy who you can be yourself with. Don't let anyone try to change or control you and influence you to give up aspects of yourself. That is emotional blackmail.

This guy pulled the marital nuclear bomb and destroyed your marriage. This gives you the opportunity to trade up, to put it bluntly. This guy who dumped you isn't the greatest, or he would have had more maturity and tact.

I think there's something more than just your past that has him divorcing you. I think he was regretting marriage and commitment in general. Time will tell.

<-- Rate this answer

A male reader, anonymous, writes (9 October 2010):

When a man says he can't picture you being the mother of his children then it's serious. That is a difference in values big enough to break a relationship. The stuff about male egos and insecurities is not tackling what is wrong here.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, DenimandLace44 United States +, writes (8 October 2010):

DenimandLace44 agony auntI'm sorry for your pain. I think the ball is in his court. Hopefully, he will get his mind wrapped around this, but if he doesn't, you will get thru this. How horrible to find that the man you thought would love you thru anything, can't deal with the answer to the question he asked. That is the danger of questions. sigh....I'm really sorry honey.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, Delilah12 United States +, writes (6 October 2010):

You are well rid of him. If he had questions like this, he should have asked them before marriage. You did nothing wrone except choose a rather rotten egg. In time, you'll get over this, and you'll have better luck next time

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, anonymous, writes (5 October 2010):

Im sorry you are going through this, but I really do think that despite how childish he was about it he did the right thing.It would have been a lot worse if he stayed and tormented you over this for years. It would have been damaging to you, the marriage and his self esteem if he stayed and constantly replayed the images in his mind.

Seriously, its difficult now and I get it but you will feel better one day.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, anonymous, writes (5 October 2010):

with conversations and fights you have had with him. it looks hard now. Obviously you asked him to leave multiple times and that is what he did.

The best thing will be to wait and watch. let the time heal the wound in his heart. Obviously one's KARMAs are always with himself or her self, so you can not get away from your past and now you have not so good past and again that led to not so good past and this will continue till some time.

Try to do as good things as possible and results will be good.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, Aunty BimBim Australia +, writes (5 October 2010):

Aunty BimBim agony auntI was going to say "what an ass" but I am aware differnt meanings of the word here and in US, so I will say, what a donkey!

It's easy to see your heart is breaking over this, he certainly has chosen his path, I am sure you will find yours, just work your way through the grief and the hurt, you will come out the other end of this stronger and more resilient.

Good luck!

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A male reader, ChaseTerrier United States +, writes (5 October 2010):

I do not know what you did in your past that you are not so proud about so he might have a reason to be upset for a little while (a week at the longest). But he should have gotten over it and not be a small child about it.

I think he was lazy and did not want to work on the marriage. He should have admit he had a problem getting over it and ask you to go see a marriage counselor together.

If you two decide to try to work things out, try to work it out with a professional counselor.

If you do ever decide to get remarried to another guy, I would recommend you and the new guy to go to Pre-Marriage Counseling.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, anonymous, writes (5 October 2010):

your husband is messed up in the head, it's better that you're rid of him, anyway, and I'm so so sorry for what you're having to go through... love is amazing when it is good, but when its bad, its very very bad... every person on this earth is different, you never know what you're going to get... your personal lesson to learn from this is to share everything about yourself before marriage... not sure what other lesson there is, maybe you know of one... but all I can see is that your exhusband is immature and messed up in the head... I guess he just assumed you were a certain way and never bothered to ask you these questions before he married you, if certains aspects of your past before meeting him are so important to him, he should have asked you this before marrying you...

People really suck sometimes...

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, siss United States +, writes (5 October 2010):

siss agony auntI am truelly sorry for the situation you are in but I do understand what you are going through. My advice and it is just advice. Is Number one your past is your past that is were it belongs. People think they can handle things but they cant. Seriously the person loves you for who they know not the person they don't. Even though best friends lovers etc. there are just some things you keep to yourself.

To ask you that question after marriage was he looking for something to be angry about?

Number Two: I commend you for your strength and realizing that it was time to let go. If he reacted the way he did you would probably never have heard the end of it. And no One wants to live with their past being thrown in their face thats why its in the past.... and also what would your future be like he seems he was a bit controlling,

Be strong Love yourself your better than that

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A male reader, lionelhutz United States +, writes (5 October 2010):

I don't believe in lying but I believe our past is our past and there's nothing wrong with keeping a few things for ourselves.

As to your experience, call me flat out wrong but reading your story I get the feeling that once you were married, either the "real" person your ex is came out or he couldn't handle marriage and was looking for any way out. I mean if you're going to make a big deal (which he shouldn't have) of your partner's past, why do it AFTER you are married?

I'm sorry to hear how things went for you but look at it this way, it happened now and not after you had invested 5, 10, 15 years into marriage.

all the best

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, janniepeg Canada +, writes (5 October 2010):

janniepeg agony auntI would like to say that a lot of men are not like that. He's probably suffering from retroactive jealousy. This term has been talked a lot on this site and no successful advice has been offered so far I know. There are many people posting their stories and the conclusion seems to be that if you can't deal with her past, don't get involved a person with a past, or ask about it. He did the right thing for himself. There is no need to regret what you told him. It's better to show your real self than to lie about who you are. The way you worded it, "strictly asked me if I had anything about the past I wanted to share," sounds very paranoid to me, like interrogation. He's a weird guy. He's looking for faults rather than trying to understand you better. The timing is also off. Why not ask before the marriage? I have a suspicion that you got married and have an active sex life, he's worried about his size, his performance and was wondering if you had had someone bigger. So it's his insecurity, rather than your ability to be a good wife and mother. Some men had a way to blame the women for their shortcummings, making themselves right, and you wrong. He saw you being sad, yet he invited you to dinner. What kind of sadistic behavior is that? See, there's something wrong with him. I just pointed out 3 negative things about him. It's good that you didn't continue this marriage.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A male reader, anonymous, writes (5 October 2010):

i think we owe each the details of our pasts...like an odometer on a vehicle that helps us decide whether or not we should purchase it. i also firmly believe that the things we do that we are not proud of say alot about our moral character. when my daughter dated a player I warned her she would be sorry. sure enough he f*cked her until he was bored and moved on. you did the right thing by sharing your past. I'm anxious to tell my girlfriend because i want her to accept me in a way that malkes me feel free and open. so, in short you did the right thing and when you find a man that will accept your past just the way it is...you will be on your way to a cleaner, stress free life. good luck.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, heart-shaped-balloon United States +, writes (5 October 2010):

heart-shaped-balloon agony auntHmm.. I know it seems hard right now, but this will be what's better for you. True love involves loving someone despite their mistakes and flaws.. My fiance has a very bad past, but he has worked up from it and it made him who he is today.. I love him for it all. He loves me too, despite my many flaws. This is true love, and it does exist. You obviously just weren't quite right for each other-- plus, if he honestly loved you like he thought he did, he wouldn't have hurt you so badly. He tortured you and didn't seem to care at all about its effects on you or your wellbeing.

People really show their true selves when things are negative.. It's easy to be perfect when everything is great, but you really show your true colors when things aren't.

It will be hard, but you made the right choice. It wasn't going to work either way, and you were right about telling him when you did. You told him something personal when you were comfortable enough to tell him. It's YOUR secret, and you should only have to tell him about it once you are comfortable enough to share it. It's your right.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A male reader, anonymous, writes (5 October 2010):

Well, this is really a "new" breach, regardless of what happened, when it happened, and the devil is in the details.

? What did you divulge? This is important.

? Do you have any intention of every working this out? This is important.

When will you get over this? Well, the information above will help you figure that out. Get a counselor to help you, yourself, and see where you can go.

Irregardless of what it was that caused this to happen, there is hope for the future, if not with him then with someone else.

Good Luck.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A male reader, Jmtmj Australia +, writes (5 October 2010):

Jmtmj agony auntSad story :(

When you think about it in a positive light, this is probably for the best. At least he realized that this was something that he couldn't live with without resenting you for and didn't drag it out. Who knows how his resentment could have manifested itself over time... but it certainly wasn't going to end in him eventually thinking of you as an equal.

Hopefully the next guy won't be as insecure and judgemental of your past.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

Add your answer to the question "Husband after marriage asked about my past and then served me with divorce papers!"

Already have an account? Login first
Don't have an account? Register in under one minute and get your own agony aunt column - recommended!

All Content Copyright (C) DearCupid.ORG 2004-2008 - we actively monitor for copyright theft

0.0312930000000051!