New here? Register in under one minute   Already a member? Login245057 questions, 1084625 answers  

  DearCupid.ORG relationship advice
  Got a relationship, dating, love or sex question? Ask for help!Search
 New Questions Answers . Most Discussed Viewed . Unanswered . Followups . Forums . Top agony aunts . About Us .  Articles  . Sitemap

9-year relationship ends because "his heart wasn't in it?" Why if I was such a "catch" did he admit that he didn't appreciate me?

Tagged as: Breaking up<< Previous question   Next question >>
Question - (24 July 2008) 6 Answers - (Newest, 25 November 2008)
A female United States age 36-40, anonymous writes:

I was just dumped after a 9 year relationship. I am having such a hard time getting over it since we still share the same interests ( so i run into him often), the same friends, and we live within walking distance of one another. This guy was my high-school sweetheart though we have broken up in the past to date other people.

I thought this was out of his system, but I see now that once again he has returned to his thought process that "the grass is greener on the other side." I am currently working on my grad degree and have had two high-profile career jobs since completely my undergrad.

He is 25 now and still has not finished his undergrad.... really he had nothing to offer. In addition, it boggles my mind that countless people would tell him how lucky he was to have a girl like me... successful, caring, non-judgemental, and beautiful. He would always be offended when people would refer to me as being "our of his league." In his break-up speak he said that he "knew that he wouldn't find anyone that would ever be better than me, but that he thinks that there is someone better suited for him than me."

Keep in mind this guy has said this in the past and ran back 6 months after the fact numerous times. I am having a hard time understanding why I see him out doing things with people that he would never do with me (baseball games, amusement parks, etc.) especially when that is all I ever wanted from him was to approach life with a more "fun-loving" attitude. Why was this not possible with me and will he be as competetive with someone new? He thinks that I am blindsided and do not see that he is trying to date everyone I know. He has even gone as far as trying to blind date people off the internet.

My family and friends are glad to see that he is gone because they knew that the way he treated me so competetively and non-jealous about other guys and non-caring about anything important was a sign that he was not in love with me.

And I admit that I would go out of my way to no end to do things for him with the knowledge that I would receive nothing in return. Is this guy going to pull a 180 and treat the next girl like gold? Why if I was such a "catch" did he admit that he didn't appreciate me? How can I get over this when every adult memory I have involves "us"?

View related questions: the internet

<-- Rate this Question

Reply to this Question


Share

Fancy yourself as an agony aunt? Add your answer to this question!

A female reader, xuxa33 United States +, writes (25 November 2008):

Hello,I know this is a bit late, since this post is from July, but I was compelled to answer and I also wanted to see if someone would write back. You know, your situation is so familiar to me because, I too was in a 8 year relationship with someone who made promises to me and chose to move on. He was not a provider, he abandoned me regularly, he lied to me, he physically abused me at times, he was just horrible. I tried to focus on myself and go to school, and do all of the things I was suspose to do, I guess my only fault was wanting him to keep the promises he made to me. He use to treat me good at times, pumping my head up to believe that I was so special. I use to chase him down just to get him back so I could hear him tell me how wonderful I was. I now see that this was very unhealthy to do. He is currently in a mental hospital. He goes there when he wants to break up with me. I believe this time it is truly over. I guess this is the hard thing to do, to try and forget all of the lies he told to us. I believe you and I will eventually find the right person for us. I also believe in karma. If he did do you wrong, he did you right by letting you go now. Now we are able to find someone more responsible and caring to love us. If nhe does find someone else to be with, remember that nothing last forever, both good and bad things must come to an end eventually. Take from this statement what ever you need to get you through your time. For me, it is knowing that his happiness will come to an end one day as will mine when I find it again. I guess we should just make lemonade out of the lemons they gave us. We will love again, and we deserve it in return.

<-- Rate this answer

A reader, anonymous, writes (25 July 2008):

This is verified as being by the original poster of the question

I am thinking... wow shouldn't have wrote the initial post when I was so angry that he is dating a friends of mine... I have no displayed this situation in the right light. I understand that comments like, " she is out of your league" were detrimental to him and so when I would hear someone start a conversation like this, especially in front of him, I would put it to an end quickly. My goal was never to make him feel inadequete... and to be honest, he feels inadequete in many other aspects of his life unrelated to our relationship. He was always measuring himself to the next guy or his sisters or me. I would always remind him that everyone's circumstances are different and that yes, we would all end up the same place sometime soon and not to worry because light was at the end of the tunnel as far as his schooling was concerned. Overall, I am not upset that I have been dumped... granted no one does, but I really miss him. I really loved and embraced him for who he was no matter what. He has already told me that he knows he will not find someone who loves and cares for him more than I did... this makes me hurt more. I love him and what him to be happy and yes, selfishly I want that to be with me because he made me happy. I just don't know where we went wrong.... he says it has everything to do with being committment phobic since he has never had another serious relationship besides myself?

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A reader, anonymous, writes (25 July 2008):

This is verified as being by the original poster of the question

I think that my initial post has been a bit misunderstood. I am simply telling you all what has been told to me.... people tell me I was too good for him... including his family. Honestly, I DON'T feel this way and that is half the problem. I was presenting the obvious when I say " yes, I am further along in life than he is." By no means did I ever hold our relationship to a certain "esteem." Never did I ever point out that I had a better job or better education... he did. He was the one who was highly competetive... not me. I accepted him for who he was and am simply trying to convince myself that I shouldn't be upset by highlighting what has been highlighted to me over the years. I do not feel that I have an ego, and yes I am defensive to posting one. The truth is, I did everything I could to stand by this guy and make him feel worth his weight in gold. For whatever reason though, my success weighed on him and that was completely beyond my control. I mean I would go above and beyond whenever possible to do absolutely anything for him. I never felt better than him... but everyone else was constantly pointing this out. Now that it is over, I only have this to hold on to... forgive me if I sound like I have an ego but the way I am speaking is the only way I can calm myself down about the situation.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A reader, anonymous, writes (25 July 2008):

This is verified as being by the original poster of the question

I think that my initial post has been a bit misunderstood. I am simply telling you all what has been told to me.... people tell me I was too good for him... including his family. Honestly, I DON'T feel this way and that is half the problem. I was presenting the obvious when I say " yes, I am further along in life than he is." By no means did I ever hold our relationship to a certain "esteem." Never did I ever point out that I had a better job or better education... he did. He was the one who was highly competetive... not me. I accepted him for who he was and am simply trying to convince myself that I shouldn't be upset by highlighting what has been highlighted to me over the years. I do not feel that I have an ego, and yes I am defensive to posting one. The truth is, I did everything I could to stand by this guy and make him feel worth his weight in gold. For whatever reason though, my success weighed on him and that was completely beyond my control. I mean I would go above and beyond whenever possible to do absolutely anything for him. I never felt better than him... but everyone else was constantly pointing this out. Now that it is over, I only have this to hold on to... forgive me if I sound like I have an ego but the way I am speaking is the only way I can calm myself down about the situation.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, dearkelja United States +, writes (25 July 2008):

dearkelja agony auntYou made the statement, "really he had nothing to offer". When we feel that way about people, they sense it. I am sure you started out on the same path but when your job and education surpassed his it was an issue he couldn't deal with. It must have made him feel inadequate and he just didn't feel good about himself. Can you imagine hearing "she's out of your league". Don't think about it in your terms (because you come out smelling like a rose) but for him to be hearing that constantly hearing that makes him feel like a loser. Think how he felt. Even if he wasn't comparing himself to you, his pals were, your family was and sounds to me like you might have been too. You mentioned that he was competitive but I could sense in your post that perhaps you were also at a minimum comparing your situation to his.

I absolutely understand your wanting to enjoy life and not let the status thing affect your relationship. At the end of the day it's all about whether or not you've had fun. But I will say there are plenty of men out there with your background who want to enjoy the same things as you.

There are many couples that get together that don't have similar backgrounds and where there are wide wage and/or educational swings but it's typically a man who is at the higher level. Some men's ego's can handle it, some can not when it's the other way around.

I am sure your ex isn't having the time of his life but the situation just couldn't be tolerated by him anymore. He's moved on to try and find some peace and someone who makes him feel adequate or perhaps even superior.

So, as Tisha says, maybe a blessing in disguise. As for how to get over your ex, time. Time and eventually a new man. Take care and get back out there.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

A female reader, Tisha-1 United States +, writes (24 July 2008):

Tisha-1 agony auntHi, I'm sorry to hear that you have suffered from this break up. It's a little bit like a divorce, since you've been together for so long.

It's actually probably best that you two did split up, as you seem to have been moving in different directions. You sound like you don't actually have much respect for his education and his career, such as they are. You've obviously outgrown him on this one.

You've wanted him to become more funloving and spontaneous, but alas, he only did this after he broke up with you.

Your last question, "How can I get over this when every adult memory I have involves "us"? " Well, you can and you will. Just because someone was close to us in youth doesn't mean that they are the right person for you to marry or to be involved with for the rest of your life. The thing is that you are in the acute stages of the mourning for a lost relationship. You're wishing things could go back to the way they were, and unfortunately, this isn't going to happen. You're mourning the lost love, and all the time and effort and energy you put into the relationship. You know something? It was all good at the start and sounds like it was pretty bad at the end.

You'll be able to get that energy and excitement and feeling of connectedness again, it'll just be with a new man.

It's not easy to get over a break up, especially if you weren't the initiator and even more so if you feel that you were the one with all the good stuff and initiative and the education and the drive.

You're going to have to let this go. Tough as it sounds, you're going to have to let him go. He's not going to admit that you were the better partner, that you were smarter and more successful and better educated and with a better take on life because you were more fun and spontaneous and all that.

Your family and your friends who love you and want the best for you, have seen that he wasn't the right guy for you. Listen to them. Just hanging on because he's the only guy you've ever dated is a really bad idea. That sounds like you're afraid of the new. That sounds like even though you're miles ahead of him in academic accomplishments, you're still the same little girl you were when you two started dating.

He's moved on, he may not have grown up, but he's moved on. And you need to let this go now. He may someday come back and say that he made the biggest mistake of his life by letting you go because you were such a catch. Then again, he might not.

Don't sit and wait for him just because you think that because he's in every memory to date that he needs to be in every one from now on. You'll make new memories, and this will fade into insignificance. At least into the insignificance with which you regard his accomplishments and his life up till now. If you can't respect him, and his choices, then any relationship you have in the future is doomed.

It sounds to me that you are more upset at being dumped than by losing him, because you were dumped by a man who wasn't worthy of you and didn't realize it.

You WILL get past this, you WILL survive. There is a guy out there who is more your type. So this may be a blessing in disguise. What do your family and friends say about this? They're happy you split up? That should tell you a lot. The people who love you best are hoping that this relationship would end. Hmmm.

Worth thinking about.

Best wishes.

<-- Rate this answer

...............................   

Add your answer to the question "9-year relationship ends because "his heart wasn't in it?" Why if I was such a "catch" did he admit that he didn't appreciate me?"

Already have an account? Login first
Don't have an account? Register in under one minute and get your own agony aunt column - recommended!

All Content Copyright (C) DearCupid.ORG 2004-2008 - we actively monitor for copyright theft

0.0937654999997903!